Peanut Butter Overnight Oats With Yogurt
Creamy peanut butter overnight oats with yogurt, made with simple ingredients for an easy, healthy, make-ahead breakfast.
Make creamy protein overnight oats with Greek yogurt, protein powder, and rolled oats. This easy, no-cook breakfast is perfect for meal prep!
Ask your favorite AI assistant to summarize this recipe, suggest swaps, or scale it up — one click away.
We copy the prompt to your clipboard too — just paste (Ctrl/Cmd+V) if it doesn't appear automatically.
Protein overnight oats are a simple no-cook breakfast made by soaking rolled oats with milk, Greek yogurt and protein powder. As the oats sit in the fridge, they become soft, creamy and ready to eat the next morning.
They are a great choice when you want a high-protein breakfast without spending much time in the kitchen. You can prepare them the night before, keep them in the fridge and have an easy make-ahead breakfast ready for a busy morning.
These healthy overnight oats are also easy to change to your taste. Add your favorite fruit, nut butter, or other toppings to make a breakfast that feels a little different each time. Whether you are planning breakfast for the week or just need something quick before starting your day, protein overnight oats are an easy and filling option.


The biggest reason these oats are high in protein is the combination of protein powder and Greek yogurt. Together, they give the recipe a much bigger protein boost than regular overnight oats made with oats and milk alone.
Protein powder is the main source of extra protein here. That is what turns a simple bowl of oats into a more protein-packed breakfast. Greek yogurt adds even more protein while also making the oats thick and creamy.
The type of milk you use also matters. Dairy milk and some higher-protein plant milks can add a little more protein, while regular almond milk usually adds less. The oats themselves provide some protein too and toppings such as nut butter or seeds can add a little extra.
The exact protein per serving will depend on the brands and amounts you use. For example, different protein powders can have very different protein amounts per scoop. So if you are trying to increase the protein in your breakfast, check the nutrition label on your protein powder and milk.
If you are wondering how to add protein to overnight oats, using protein powder along with Greek yogurt is one of the easiest options. You can also increase the protein by choosing a higher-protein milk or adding a spoonful of nut butter or seeds.

Getting creamy overnight oats is mostly about choosing the right oats and getting the liquid balance right. A few small steps can make a big difference in the final texture.
Rolled oats, also called old-fashioned oats, are usually the best oats for overnight oats. They soften in the fridge while still keeping some texture. Quick oats become softer, while instant oats can turn quite mushy. Steel-cut oats are much firmer and need a different soaking method, so they are not the best choice for this recipe.
The amount of liquid matters too. Protein powder can absorb quite a bit of liquid and chia seeds thicken the mixture as they sit. Different protein powders can also behave differently, so you may need a little more or less milk depending on the brand you use.
For a smooth consistency, stir everything really well at first. Let the mixture sit for a few minutes, then give it another good stir. This helps spread the chia seeds and protein powder evenly and can help prevent protein powder clumps.
If your overnight oats are too thick or too dry the next morning, simply stir in a small splash of milk. If they are too watery, give them more time in the fridge or add a little extra oats or chia seeds. The goal is a thick and creamy texture that is soft enough to spoon easily.

Nutrition per serving:
Nutrition values are estimates and can vary depending on the protein powder, Greek yogurt, milk and other brands used.
The basic recipe is easy to change when you want a different flavor. Keep the same base and add a few simple ingredients to make each jar taste a little different.
For a richer flavor, use chocolate protein powder or add a little cocoa powder to the base. Stir in peanut butter for a creamy, nutty taste. Sliced banana and a few chocolate chips are also great if you want something sweeter.
Add mashed banana to the oat mixture for natural sweetness and a soft banana flavor. A little cinnamon works really well here. You can also add peanut butter or almond butter for extra richness.
Mix in strawberries, blueberries, or raspberries before serving, or use a mix of your favorite berries. Fresh berries give a brighter flavor, while frozen berries work well when fresh fruit is not available.
Add diced or grated apple and a little extra cinnamon for a simple apple-cinnamon flavor. A small drizzle of maple syrup can make it sweeter, while chopped nuts add a nice crunch. For another cozy breakfast with apple and cinnamon flavors, try Apple Pie Overnight Oats for a simple make-ahead option.
For a simple, classic option, use vanilla protein powder with the vanilla extract already in the base. Top it with berries or banana, or add a spoonful of nut butter for a richer breakfast.

Once your oats are ready, a few simple toppings can make them more fun and flavorful. You do not need much a small handful or spoonful is usually enough.
Fresh fruit is an easy choice. Try sliced banana, strawberries, blueberries, or raspberries for natural sweetness and a fresh taste.
For something richer, add a spoonful of peanut butter or almond butter. If you like some crunch, try chopped walnuts, almonds, seeds, or a little granola.
You can also finish your overnight oats toppings with shredded coconut, a few chocolate chips, or a light sprinkle of cinnamon. Mix and match based on what you already have at home. For extra crunch, serve your overnight oats with Homemade Granola, which adds texture and flavor to a creamy breakfast.

This recipe is flexible, so you can easily change a few ingredients based on your preference or what is available in your kitchen.
Milk: Regular dairy milk can be replaced with almond milk, soy milk, or another plant-based milk. Keep in mind that the protein amount may change depending on the milk you choose.
Protein powder: You can use whey protein or a plant-based protein powder in vanilla, chocolate, or an unflavored option. Different powders absorb liquid differently, so adjust the milk if the mixture becomes too thick.
Yogurt: Greek yogurt gives the oats a thick and creamy texture. For dairy-free protein overnight oats, use a suitable dairy-free yogurt and check that your protein powder is also dairy-free.
Sweetener: Use maple syrup or honey depending on how sweet you like your oats. For a vegan version, choose maple syrup instead of honey.
Seeds: Chia seeds can be replaced or partly mixed with ground flax seeds. Both can add fiber and help give the oats a thicker texture.
For an extra protein boost, you can also add nut butter or a small amount of cottage cheese. If making vegan protein overnight oats, use plant-based ingredients throughout, including vegan protein powder and yogurt.
For gluten-free overnight oats, use certified gluten-free oats. Always check the labels of packaged protein powders and other ingredients if you need to avoid gluten or dairy.

Protein overnight oats are a great option for breakfast meal prep because you can make several servings at once. Prepare the jars on one day, place them in the fridge and you have a ready-to-eat breakfast waiting for you on busy mornings.
For easy meal prep overnight oats, divide the mixture between mason jars or other clean airtight containers. Keep them refrigerated until you are ready to eat them. Properly stored, they are best enjoyed within 3 to 4 days.
If you are preparing several jars for the week, keep fresh fruit and crunchy toppings separate when possible. Add them just before eating so the fruit stays fresh and granola or nuts do not become soft.
The oats may become a little thicker after sitting in the fridge for a few days. If that happens, stir in a small splash of milk before serving. This keeps your make-ahead breakfast creamy and easy to eat.

A serving of this recipe provides approximately 26 grams of protein. Most of it comes from the protein powder and Greek yogurt, while the milk and oats add smaller amounts. The exact number can change depending on the brands you use.
Yes. You can still make a protein-rich breakfast by using Greek yogurt, high-protein milk, nut butter, seeds, or a little cottage cheese. The final protein amount will be lower or higher depending on the ingredients you choose.
When kept in an airtight container and refrigerated properly, they are best eaten within 3 to 4 days. If they develop an unusual smell, appearance, or texture, it is better to discard them.
Yes, you can enjoy them warm if you prefer. Transfer the oats to a microwave-safe container and heat them gently, stirring once or twice. Add a splash of milk if they become too thick while warming.
Rolled oats or old-fashioned oats are usually the best choice because they soften overnight while keeping a pleasant texture. Quick oats become softer, while steel-cut oats stay much firmer and need a different preparation method.
For thicker overnight oats, use Greek yogurt or a little extra chia seeds and give the mixture enough time to chill. You can also add a small amount of extra oats. If the mixture is already too thick, add a splash of milk instead.
Make creamy protein overnight oats with Greek yogurt, protein powder, and rolled oats. This easy, no-cook breakfast is perfect for meal prep!
Good to know
Made this recipe?
Tag @themealprepideas on Instagram — we love seeing what you made.
Be the first to rate, review, or ask a question about this recipe.
No comments yet
Be the first cook to share feedback or ask a question about this recipe!
Keep Cooking
Creamy peanut butter overnight oats with yogurt, made with simple ingredients for an easy, healthy, make-ahead breakfast.
Make perfect hard-boiled eggs with firm whites, tender yolks, easy peeling, and simple tips for breakfast, snacks, and meal prep.
Make fluffy High Protein Pancakes with cottage cheese, oats, eggs, and protein powder for an easy, protein-packed breakfast perfect for meal prep!
Join 50,000+ subscribers getting weekly meal prep ideas, shopping lists, and time-saving tips straight to their inbox.